| Name | Pos | Team | Age | DOB | POB | Nationality | Bats | Throws | Height | Weight | Salary | | Caldwell, George | C | Buffalo Bluebirds | 34 | 03/11/1854 | Troy | USA | Switch | Right | 5' 11" | 180 lbs | - | | Cameron, Tom | RP | Allentown Peanuts | 21 | 11/05/1866 | Lima | USA | Switch | Right | 6' 0" | 190 lbs | - | | Campbell, Jim | 3B | Providence Planters | 23 | 03/16/1865 | North Royalton | USA | Switch | Right | 5' 11" | 175 lbs | - | | Carder, Donald | 2B | Buffalo Bluebirds | 28 | 09/09/1860 | San Jose | USA | Right | Right | 5' 9" | 175 lbs | - | | Carey, Edgar | CF | Providence Planters | 30 | 09/11/1858 | Cincinnati | USA | Switch | Right | 5' 10" | 180 lbs | - | | Castle, George | RP | Allentown Peanuts | 18 | 03/20/1870 | Fair Oaks | USA | Left | Right | 6' 1" | 200 lbs | - | | Chambers, Jack | 2B | Newark Smiths | 27 | 10/19/1861 | Richmond | USA | Right | Right | 6' 0" | 175 lbs | - | | Charles, Joe | RP | Scranton Anthracites | 23 | 07/11/1865 | Eastpointe | USA | Right | Right | 6' 0" | 155 lbs | - | | Chase, Dick | C | Albany Dutchmen | 28 | 01/07/1860 | Perinton | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 190 lbs | - | | Chase, Wilbur | 1B | Troy Rivermen | 34 | 12/20/1853 | Braintree | USA | Right | Right | 6' 0" | 155 lbs | - | | Clair, Richard | SS | Albany Dutchmen | 23 | 03/23/1865 | Bridgeport | USA | Switch | Right | 5' 9" | 175 lbs | - | | Columbus, Steve | 3B | Newark Smiths | 34 | 05/05/1854 | Valley View (Schuylkill County) | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 175 lbs | - | | Comstock, John | CF | Scranton Anthracites | 24 | 11/13/1863 | Brockton | USA | Switch | Left | 5' 8" | 160 lbs | - | | Creasy, Chris | SP | Scranton Anthracites | 23 | 02/16/1865 | Roseville | USA | Right | Right | 6' 0" | 210 lbs | - | | Cummings, Richard | SS | Buffalo Bluebirds | 28 | 02/12/1860 | Shawnee | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 190 lbs | - | |